In an ideal world, the food we reach for out of convenience would always align seamlessly with our nutritional goals, offering a harmonious blend of great taste, ease, and optimal health. Unfortunately, the modern food landscape is defined by daily tradeoffs. Human biology easily craves the immediate gratification of ice cream, potato chips, and candy bars, making carbohydrates and fats effortless to over-consume. Meeting daily protein targets, on the other hand, frequently demands a conscientious, deliberate effort—particularly for individuals who prefer to limit their consumption of meat or animal-based proteins.
Fortunately, as food and tech observers have recently noted, a wave of both nimble startups and established food brands are working to bridge this gap, making it simpler than ever for consumers to boost their daily protein intake. From carbonated beverages and snack bars to frozen desserts, grocery store shelves are rapidly evolving. It is now entirely possible to acquire a substantial fix of this coveted macronutrient through packaged foods and drinks that were historically associated strictly with sugar, starch, and fat.
Yet, as this new generation of products floods the market, a looming, inevitable question remains for everyday shoppers: Do they actually taste good?
To find out how these modern formulations fare outside the laboratory, a trip was made to a local Target store to curate a diverse selection of protein-forward foods manufactured by venture-backed startups. Accompanied by a 10-year-old co-taster, these products were subjected to a rigorous, real-world household taste test.
The ultimate verdict? Most of these items are indeed entirely edible and drinkable, though they are almost never nearly as tasty as their more protein-deficient, traditional supermarket counterparts—with just one notable exception.
Here is what the testing revealed across seven distinct products.
No. 1: David Vanilla Bean Frozen Dessert
Any consumer who buys or consumes the David Vanilla Bean Frozen Dessert will undoubtedly be doing so for the nutritional payoff rather than out of pure culinary desire. Manufactured by Medici Brands, the parent company behind the David brand, a single pint packs a staggering 30 grams of protein while keeping its calorie count down to a modest 210 calories.
From a structural standpoint, the texture is remarkably on point. It is genuinely creamy, easy to scoop with a spoon, and carries a distinct, recognizable vanilla flavor profile. That being said, the product cannot completely hide the underlying reality that it is not formulated with traditional ice cream ingredients. Shoppers who harbor an aversion to artificial sweeteners, or who dislike the distinct flavor and mouthfeel associated with whey protein, will likely want to pass on this option. However, for the author and the young co-taster, it provided a reasonably appealing eating experience. It certainly falls short of traditional, premium ice cream, but it represents an impressive feat for a high-protein alternative.
No. 2: SkyPop Protein Soda
The nutritional statistics boasted by SkyPop Protein Soda—formerly operating under the moniker Don’t Quit—are similarly remarkable. A standard 12-ounce can contains a mere 45 calories, accompanied by 10 grams of protein and just a single gram of total carbohydrates. Furthermore, it delivers a proper, lively fizz, producing a satisfying pop upon opening the can.
When it comes to flavor, however, the experience was more mixed. The local retail store only had the Ice Pop flavor available on shelves. In the shared view of both tasters, the beverage was not entirely horrible, but it failed to inspire a desire for regular, recurring purchases. Nevertheless, it is easy to imagine consuming a product like this when navigating a restricted clear-fluid diet, such as the preparations often required prior to specific medical procedures, where it would stand out as one of the very few accessible sources of dietary protein.
No. 3: Khloud Protein Popcorn
Unlike many of the heavily fortified items dominating the modern functional food sector, Khloud Protein Popcorn does not present itself as a super-dense protein offering. A standard serving contains 7 grams of protein alongside 160 calories, the vast majority of which naturally originate from carbohydrates and fats inherent to the snack. Even so, its protein count remains notably higher than standard commercial packaged popcorn, which typically yields roughly 2 grams of protein in a comparable serving size.
Evaluating the White Cheddar variety from Khloud, the tasters concluded that it functions as a genuinely decent snack food. The underlying taste of milk protein and whey protein concentrate was perceptible on the palate, but it never crossed the line into becoming overwhelming. While it may not be a snack food one would actively sit down to savor, it successfully serves its purpose as a casual, mindless munchie to keep at an office desk or consume while watching a television show.
No. 4: Mosh Protein Bars
In a notable pop culture parallel, the third season of the satirical television series "The White Lotus" features co-founder Patrick Schwarzenegger portraying a fitness-and-finance archetype who prepares a daily high-protein shake that leaves his fictional family members visibly revolted. Perhaps this on-screen moment drew indirect inspiration from Mosh, the brain-supporting protein bar startup that Schwarzenegger launched alongside his mother, media figure Maria Shriver.
The Mosh bar, evaluated here in the peanut butter cup flavor, successfully crams 20 grams of protein, 6 grams of dietary fiber, and a suite of specialized brain-supporting ingredients—such as creatine and lion’s mane mushroom—into a compact, shelf-stable format. It is undeniably an impressive nutritional feat. Yet, while our brains may have intellectually appreciated the concentrated nutrient and supplement boost provided by the Mosh bar, our taste buds decidedly did not share the enthusiasm.
This places Mosh firmly in the category of functional foods. It is a product you might strategically consume if you specifically desire that exact matrix of nutrients, but it is rarely something one would choose to ingest purely for sensory pleasure.
No. 5: Cadootz Crackers
Evaluating two distinct varieties of Cadootz Crackers—cheddar and sea salt—the testing team walked away feeling neither particularly enthused nor overtly repulsed by the experience.
For consumers actively searching for a gluten-free and seed-oil-free snack cracker that delivers approximately 5 grams of protein per serving, Cadootz rises to the occasion. The product delivers a satisfying crunch and a reasonably pleasant baseline flavor profile. As someone who does not harbor a strict dietary need to avoid gluten and seed oils, and who does not necessarily look to crackers for a modest protein bump, future purchases will likely be bypassed. However, for its specific, highly engaged target audience, Cadootz should serve its purpose quite well.
No. 6: Frozen One
For any consumer who might have walked away thinking the David frozen dessert was a pinnacle of modern protein engineering, the product developers at Frozen One are ready to enter the conversation. Their specialized protein ice cream formulation packs an astonishing 40 grams of protein into every single pint.
The critical question remains: How does it taste? According to the two-person tasting team, it is not entirely bad. Having sampled both the chocolate and apple pie varieties, the testers leaned favorably toward the chocolate option. Much like the David offering, Frozen One inevitably tastes like a manufactured product constructed from milk protein concentrate and sugar substitutes. Consumers will not mistake it for a traditional luxury pint from a brand like Ben and Jerry’s. However, if the overarching objective is to consume a steak-like quantity of protein presented in the comforting form factor of a pint of ice cream, the product ultimately does its job.
No. 7: Brami Protein Pasta
The tasting team saved what turned out to be the absolute best for last. Somewhat unexpectedly, that crown went to Brami Protein Pasta, an innovative noodle crafted from a blend of semolina and lupini beans. The product boasts roughly 70 percent more protein than standard, traditional pasta, alongside more than double the dietary fiber content.
Providing roughly 12 grams of protein for a 200-calorie serving, Brami is not engineered to act as a hyper-dense protein source on its own. However, when paired with the right sauce or topping, it is more than sufficient to transform an ordinarily starchy noodle dish into something reasonably and efficiently protein-rich.
Most importantly, Brami genuinely tastes quite good, completely lacking any discernible, unpleasant chemical aftertaste or problematic textural anomalies during consumption. To verify this, standard wheat noodles were prepared alongside the Brami noodles for a direct side-by-side comparison. When it came time to reach for a second helping, the testers unanimously opted for the Brami pasta.
